About Us

A vintage ice cream parlor that combines old world charm and new creamy ice cream flavors.

Toppings Ice Cream Parlor has it's home in Bluffton, Indiana.

We opened our doors on April 5, 2021 to the warm reception of the greater Bluffton community. Our ice cream shop utilizes a lot of original features of the building including the original flooring and exposed gas pipes which were used to light overhead lamps.  

The old charm of the building is maintained in the bright and welcoming atmosphere we maintain for customers. Our owners (Mari, Angie, and Chip) are servants first and we imbue that mentality in to everything we do. 

We Serve The Best Ice Cream in Town!

We searched high and low for an ice cream company that offered a wide variety of creamy, delicious flavors.

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream is our only provider of Ice Cream flavors because we think their product is the best. With over 100 different flavors that are all decadent, delicious, and butter-creamy, we know you won’t be disappointed. 


Our average customer rating is 4.8 / 5
Amazing staff and even better ice cream, I got the old fashioned vanilla and the guy behind the counter was excited because he had been trying to convince people to try it. Tasted great and was definitely made that day! Had to go back in to buy a small container for the house and leave a tip.
Happy Customer
Best Ice cream shop this side of the Mississippi! The ice cream is rich and smooth, and they come up with awesome new ways to serve ice cream so often, every one is delicious! Great people too, adds so much to a place. Amazing retro atmosphere, what more could you want?
Happy Customer

Follow us on